Participants in a pro-life rally line North Trade Street in October 2012. (photo by Samantha Hurst)
Participants in a pro-life rally line North Trade Street in October 2012. (photo by Samantha Hurst)

Archived Story

Tryon drafts picket/protest regulation

Published 2:10pm Tuesday, March 26, 2013

The Town of Tryon is considering amending its town code to  regulate pickets, demonstrations, parades and protests with careful drafting to ensure the language does not restrict anyone’s First Amendment right to free speech.

Council met March 19 and reviewed a draft ordinance to be included in the town’s code that would require a notification be submitted and restrictions regarding how close a picket, protest, demonstration or parade could be in front of open businesses.

The original draft said that a notification has to be obtained from the town if 10 or more persons want to demonstrate. Commissioners came to a consensus that they want a notification if one or more persons is going to demonstrate, picket, protest or parade in town.

The issue of the need for picketing regulations surfaced following an October 21, 2012 demonstration downtown where more than 50 members of St. John the Baptist Catholic Churched gathered along the sidewalks holding signs against abortion.

Commissioners met the next month and asked if there is anyway to regulate future protests with some saying there was an issue with the demonstration blocking businesses.

The town’s current draft amendment to the code says picketing may be conducted on public sidewalks, town-controlled parks or other town-owned areas normally used or reserved for pedestrian movement, including easements, but should not be conducted on roadways used for vehicular traffic or at a location directed, focused or targeted at a particular private residence.

Regarding businesses, the current drafts states that picketing shall not disrupt, block, obstruct or interfere with pedestrian or vehicular traffic or the free passage of pedestrian or vehicular traffic into any driveway, pedestrian entrance or other access to buildings which abut the public sidewalk. Commissioners discussed the distance picketers can be from the entrance to any open business with the current draft saying picketers shall not station themselves within 10 feet of an open business. Some commissioners were more in favor of restricting that distance to 20 feet from an entrance.

Commissioner Roy Miller said he’s pro-business and hears what others are saying about restricting protests in front of businesses, but he doesn’t want to violate anyone’s constitutional right. He said he’d like a little more time before restricting to 20 feet in front of businesses. He mentioned in the late 1990s that the Ku Klux Klan walked down Main Street in Tryon with a parade, so there has been other demonstrations here and “I’d hate to willingly go into something that may be unlawful.”

The draft also includes restrictions to placards, signs, flags or banners that might be carried by individuals during a picket.

“Written or printed placards or signs, flags or banners carried by individuals engaged in picketing shall be of such a size and/or carried on the sidewalks or other town-owned areas as to allow safe and unobstructed passage of pedestrian or vehicular traffic,” states the draft restriction. “The staff or pole on which a sign, flag or banner may be carried shall be made of corrugated material, plastic or wood and shall not exceed 40 inches in length and shall not be made of metal or metal alloy. If made of wood, the staff or pole shall be no greater than ¾ inch in diameter at any point. A staff or pole must be blunt at both ends.”

Although a public hearing is not required for this particular ordinance amendment, Tryon commissioners decided a public hearing will be held.

Town attorney Bailey Nager suggested that the town hold a public hearing in April and adopt something in May. The town plans to place the full draft on its website prior to a public hearing at Copies are also available at town hall.

  • Pingback: Free to Be Penalized for Not Following Stiff Rules – Provided Permission Is Granted | The Wild West

  • fallingman

    I appreciate the council’s concern for protecting 1st amendment rights. That should be their only concern beyond maintaining public safety.

    Were those wild and crazy St. John’s Catholics really “blocking” businesses? I think not.

    Should anyone block roadways or driveways? Should anyone carry a flag that can double as a spear? Of course not.

    Do protestors have the right to be on the sidewalk? You bet your butt they do…or let’s not call it the land of the free anymore, okay? 10 feet isn’t so close as to “block” any entrance to a business. 20 feet gets people off the sidewalk. I strongly suspect that’s why 20 feet has been proposed.

    Look folks, we aren’t stupid. Stop the subterfuge and be straight about this. You don’t like protestors protesting on Trade Street…period. You think it interferes with business. It very likely does to a small degree. LIVE WITH IT. It’s part of the price of freedom. Tolerance…which includes allowing people to peacefully be in your presence when you’d rather they not be. Gepiche?

Editor's Picks

Editorial: Divisive prayer alienated citizens

Everyone deserves the right to free speech. Few will argue this point more staunchly than those who work in the newspaper industry.  Even we have ... Read more  | 2 comments

Bathanti will judge Lanier Library’s poetry competition

North Carolina’s Poet Laureate Joseph Bathanti will judge for this year’s Sidney Lanier Poetry Competition. Bathanti is the author of eight books of poetry as ... Read more